Lesson 23 · Sentence Patterns & Pragmatics
邊個 bin1 go3, 點解 dim2 gaai2, 幾時 gei2 si4 — Cantonese question words vs Mandarin.
For Mandarin Speakers
Cantonese question word grammar is identical to Mandarin — the question word stays in situ (in the position of the answer). The vocabulary is entirely different though: every Mandarin question word has a distinct Cantonese replacement.
Cantonese question words go in the same position as Mandarin — they stay in situ (where the answer would go). The grammar is identical. The challenge is purely vocabulary: nearly every question word is different from Mandarin.
The essential question word replacements: 邊個 bin1 go3 = 誰 shuí (who), 咩 me1 = 什麼 shénme (what), 邊度 bin1 dou6 = 哪裡 nǎlǐ (where), 點解 dim2 gaai2 = 為什麼 wèishénme (why), 幾時 gei2 si4 = 什麼時候 shénme shíhòu (when), 點 dim2 / 點樣 dim2 joeng2 = 怎麼 zěnme (how).
邊 bin1 is the core question element meaning 'which'. It combines with classifiers: 邊個 bin1 go3 (which one / who), 邊度 bin1 dou6 (which place = where), 邊間 bin1 gaan1 (which shop/room). This is like Mandarin 哪 nǎ but more versatile.
幾 gei2 is used for 'how many/how much': 幾多 gei2 do1 (how many/much = 多少 duōshǎo), 幾多錢 gei2 do1 cin2 (how much money), 幾時 gei2 si4 (when = 什麼時候). Also 幾 + adjective for 'how [adjective]': 幾大 gei2 daai6 (how big), 幾遠 gei2 jyun5 (how far).
點 dim2 is another versatile question root: 點解 dim2 gaai2 (why = 為什麼), 點樣 dim2 joeng2 (how = 怎麼樣), 點算 dim2 syun3 (what to do = 怎麼辦). On its own, 點 dim2 means 'how': 點做?dim2 zou6? (How to do it?). These are extremely common in daily speech.
Mandarin: 誰來了? shuí lái le?
邊個 bin1 go3 = who — in situ, same position as Mandarin
Mandarin: 你在做什麼? nǐ zài zuò shénme?
咩 me1 = what — replaces Mandarin 什麼
Mandarin: 為什麼你不來? wèishénme nǐ bù lái?
點解 dim2 gaai2 = why — replaces Mandarin 為什麼
Mandarin: 多少錢? duōshǎo qián?
幾多 gei2 do1 = how many/much — replaces Mandarin 多少
Mandarin: 你什麼時候回來? nǐ shénme shíhòu huílái?
幾時 gei2 si4 = when — replaces Mandarin 什麼時候
Fill in the Blank
Convert to Cantonese: 為什麼?(Why?) → ___?
Multiple Choice
Match: 邊度 bin1 dou6 = ?
Translate
Translate to Cantonese (with Jyutping): 'How much does this cost?' (這個多少錢?)
Fill in the Blank
To ask 'who' in Cantonese: ___個?
Multiple Choice
What does 點算?dim2 syun3 mean?